9th Circuit Finds "Back of the House" Tip Pooling Does Not Violate FLSA

Employers may not claim tip credit against—and must pay—minimum wage

On Feb. 23, 2010, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit, in a 3-0 panel decision, held that an agreed-to tip pool requiring sharing of tips with the “back of the house” does not violate the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) where no tip credit against the minimum wage is claimed. Cumbie v. Woody Woo, Inc., ___ F.3d ___ .*

The court’s decision may be helpful to employers in the hospitality and restaurant industry that want to broaden their tip pools to back of the house employees, such as dishwashers and cooks.

Continue Reading...

Scam Alert: Oregon Restaurants and Bars Are Being Targeted!

A new scam is targeting Oregon restaurants and bars!

Oregon restaurants and bars should be aware of a new scam targeting them. The scam preys on those who may have inadvertently let their business registration status or license lapse.  The scammer sends threatening letters to these businesses and demands money in exchange for not filing complaints with the OLCC.  The scammer claims the business's failure to keep government paperwork up-to-date threatens its licensing status with the OLCC.

The scammer’s threats are largely empty. In most instances, updating your business information and corporate status with the Oregon Secretary of State and the OLCC are relatively straight forward. It is highly advisable to contact your attorney, the Oregon Secretary of State or the OLCC before responding to any such requests for money.

A business who receives this type of threatening letter is being advised by the Oregon Secretary of State to contact 1) their local police department to file a criminal complaint, 2) the OLCC at 800-452-6522, and 3) the Oregon Secretary of State Corporation Division at 503-986-2200, for assistance updating and renewing business registrations.

For more information, visit the Oregon Secretary of State at www.sos.state.or.us/corporation/scam_alert/inactive_business_OLCC_scam.htm.

DWT Congratulates its 2010 James Beard Foundation Awards Restaurant and Chef Award Semifinalists

OUTSTANDING RESTAURATEUR
Michael Dellar, Lark Creek Restaurant Group (San Francisco)
Tom Douglas, Dahlia Bakery, Dahlia Lounge, Etta’s, Lola, Palace Kitchen, Serious Pie (Seattle)

OUTSTANDING RESTAURANT
Delfina (San Francisco)

BEST NEW RESTAURANT
Ping (Portland, Ore.)

OUTSTANDING WINE AND SPIRITS PROFESSIONAL
Stephen R. McCarthy, Clear Creek Distillery (Portland, Ore.)

BEST CHEF: NORTHWEST
Jenn Louis, Lincoln (Portland, Ore.)
Andy Ricker, Pok Pok (Portland, Ore.)

Samuelsson to Open Red Rooster Harlem

Chef Marcus Samuelsson is set to open his new restaurant, Red Rooster Harlem, this fall:
www.nytimes.com/2010/02/21/fashion/21night.html

California Pizza Kitchen Announces New Franchise Partnership with USC Hospitality

DWT helps bring client California Pizza Kitchen to the University of Southern California:
www.marketwatch.com/story/california-pizza-kitchen-to-open-at-the-university-of-southern-california-2010-02-18?reflink=MW_news_stmp

Q&A on Restaurant Investments

The following is a pithy discussion on investment in the restaurant space: http://www.pehub.com/63260/qa-on-ma-roarks-steve-romaniello-on-restaurant-deals

"My landlord wants me to sign a personal guaranty ... should I?"

As published in Santé Magazine

My brother, a chef, has been looking to open his own place for a number of years now. He tells me that when he finds the perfect space, he is going to jump on it. If that happens, I’m sure that I will get a call from him asking if I have time to review his lease. He will tell me that it’s the perfect space and that I need to take only a “quick look.” He also will probably tell me that, because he’s taken my advice and set up his business as a limited liability entity, the landlord wants him to sign a personal guaranty. He will want to know what that means and whether he should sign it. Here’s what I’ll tell him: www.dwthospitalitylaw.com/uploads/file/GuestCheck-Benazzi.pdf

Daphne's Greek Café Opens on USC Campus

DWT client Daphne's Greek Café opens on the campus of USC:
http://dailytrojan.com/2010/01/15/cafe-84-adds-two-international-options

Simon Confirmed as Chef at LA's New JW Marriott

DWT client Kerry Simon confirmed as chef at the new JW Marriott Hotel in Los Angeles, which opens February 15, 2010:
http://la.eater.com/archives/2010/01/15/kerry_simon_chef_for_la_lives_jw_marriott.php

Break Bread

On September 23, top restaurant executives from around the country joined DWT and their co-hosts in Beverly Hills to "Break Bread," discussing the compelling business and legal issues facing the restaurant industry today.

Presenters included Kevin Brown, President of Lettuce Entertain You, Inc., Dick Rivera, CEO of RealMex, Jim Parrish of Parrish Partners, Mario Del Pero, President, Mendocino Farms, Tony Shure, co-founder Chop't Creative Salad Company, and chef Jose Andreas.

The presentation was followed by a lively reception.

It was DWT's third annual event in Los Angeles, hosted by national restaurant practice group chair Riley Lagesen. It has quickly become one of the "must attend" events in the restaurant industry.

Differences in Restaurant Concept May Not Be Enough to Overcome Similarities in Name for Trademark Registration Purposes

Restaurateurs recognize differences in restaurant concepts and often believe that such differences will obviate consumer confusion even when the same or similar names are used by two different concepts. Often they are right! However, the U. S. Patent and Trademark Office has its own standards and guidelines and often refuses registration of a junior applicant despite the obvious differences in concept and location. See http://thettablog.blogspot.com/2009/09/wyha-ttab-finds-lucas-chophouse.html 

Restaurateurs who seek a federal registration and/or seek to franchise should be especially aware of this.

Oregon Considering Cutting Lottery Commissions

Oregon is facing a budget crisis and Oregon Lottery profits are declining. This is a recipe for disaster for bars and taverns faced with their own economic challenges as the lottery officials debate whether to cut lottery commissions to channel more funds to prop up essential state programs like education.

Lottery commissions have been cut five times since 1992, but increased sales have generally offset the cuts. Now, with lottery sales trending down, a cut to lottery commissions could be devastating to already struggling bars and taverns.

Proponents of reducing commissions argue that the lottery’s current program amounts to a tavern welfare program and that those funds should be channeled to educational programs instead. One proposal is to reduce the commission rate from 23 percent to 15 percent. Bars and taverns argue that their margins are razor thin and that cuts in this economy could result in business closures and lost jobs. 

Tough times and tough choices.  We'll be following this issue closely and will update you here when there are new developments.

For more information, see http://www.oregonlive.com/politics/index.ssf/2009/08/oregon_eyes_taverns_and_bars_v.html.
 

Oregon DOJ is investigating issues raised in Bend's OLCC controversy

Over the last several months, Bend city councilors, Deschutes County commissioners and local bar and restaurant owners have vigorously spoken out against alleged abuses suffered by local licensees at the hands of the OLCC. The OLCC attempted to quiet their concerns through a series of town hall meetings, but the dissatisfaction has persisted. 

Now, the Oregon Department of Justice is investigating complaints raised by these groups about Bend-based OLCC enforcement agents allegedly overstepping their authority. In response to the investigation, the OLCC announced the temporary re-assignment of Regional Manager Jason Evers to Redmond pending the results of the investigation.

We’ll keep you posted as information becomes available.

For more information about the investigation, follow the link: http://www.bendbulletin.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20090804/AE02/908040422/1002.

 

Quick casual restaurants and coffee shops are increasingly adding alcohol to their menu. Should you?

Quick casual restaurants, such as Chipotle Mexican Grill, Burgerville, and Subway, and coffee shops, including Starbucks, are adding alcohol to their menus to attract customers and increase sales. Burgerville recently added wine and beer to one of its restaurants in Vancouver, Washington. Starbucks announced in July that it is re-branding one of its existing locations in Seattle to 15th Avenue Coffee and Tea and will offer wine and beer as part of this effort.

Before you jump on the bandwagon, make sure you understand what is involved in obtaining a liquor license and how it may impact your employees, operations, management and costs.

The Application. Obtaining a liquor license can be a complex, expensive process if problems arise. State liquor control commissions frequently require substantial disclosures from all owners of the business. If an applicant has had financial, legal or personal troubles or fails to disclose material information as required by state law, they may not be approved. Prospective applicants should conduct a self-assessment to identify any potential red flags before submitting an application and consult an experienced attorney to address any such issues proactively. Once the applicant receives their license, they are a “licensee” and subject to the state’s alcohol regulatory framework. For more information about how to obtain a liquor license in Oregon, visit http://www.oregon.gov/OLCC/how_to_get_a_liquor_license.shtml.

Employees. Each state has different requirements regarding the requirements for individuals that are involved in the preparation and sale of alcoholic beverages. Most states require that such individuals take a class, pass an exam and receive approval from the state liquor control commission.

In Oregon, all employees that mix, sell or serve alcohol, or that supervise others that mix, sell or serve alcohol, must have a service permit. This includes employees that ring up checks with alcohol on them, collect money from customers for alcohol, or delivery drinks to a table. To obtain a service permit, the employee must be at least 18 years old, complete an Alcohol Server Education Class and submit all the required paperwork and fees. Special restrictions apply to service permittees under the age of 20.

Operations. Licensees operating quick casual restaurants or coffee shops may need to restructure their operations to ensure compliance. It’s likely that not all of a licensee’s employees will have service permits and that some may be under 21, or even under 18. The licensee is ultimately responsible for any violation and must ensure that operations do not inadvertently result in violations. For example, individuals without server permits and those under 18 are categorically prohibited from mixing, selling or serving alcohol. Licensees are responsible for establishing policies and procedures that satisfy the state’s alcohol regulatory regime.

Ongoing Compliance. Adding a liquor license to an establishment often requires greater management oversight. Violations are time consuming and expensive, and fees and penalties typically escalate for repeat offenses. A history of violations is not only expensive, but often draws greater attention from enforcement agents and, ultimately, jeopardizes the license.

Licensees often need to have a stronger management presence at the premise to ensure compliance. Common violations are serving alcohol to minors and failure of an employee to have a non-expired service permit. However, there are many more potential pitfalls and each state presents its own unique set of rules and prohibitions. New licensees often learn the hard way when they first receive their license. The best practice is to implement a comprehensive alcohol service policy and to conduct regular, on-going trainings. Although adding alcohol to the menu generally results in increased sales, it also involves increased costs as well.

In sum, adding alcohol to the menu is often an attractive proposition, but it is not a panacea and should not be undertaken lightly. Those considering adding alcohol to their quick casual restaurant and coffee shop should look before they leap and fully understand the legal requirements of their state.

We can help in Oregon, Washington and California, or provide a reference to an attorney in any other state.
 

Oregon bars and restaurants should be careful promoting their establishment using Facebook and Twitter

Restaurants and bars, and every other type of hospitality business, are increasingly using online social media to promote their business. Twitter, Facebook and MySpace are the usual suspects today, but we can expect new entries going forward. Advertising spending in these channels is reported to have eclipsed the $100 million mark this year and is expected to increase. Yet, the dollars spent tell only part of the story. For most restaurants and bars, promoting their business using social media sites is essentially free. It’s this value proposition that promises to making such promotion ubiquitous over the next few years.

Restaurants and bars that serve alcohol must be aware that state liquor laws still apply in this brave new world of social media. A virtual violation is still a violation and can put your license in jeopardy (as well as your pocketbook)!

In Oregon, “advertising” is defined broadly as “publicizing the trade name of a license together with words or symbols referring to alcoholic beverages or publicizing the brand name of an alcoholic beverage.” The OLCC prohibits advertising that, among other things, (1) promotes happy hours involving the temporary reduction in alcoholic beverage prices, (2) encourage drinking because of its intoxicating effect or encourages drinking to excess, (3) involves instantly redeemable coupons for alcoholic beverages, or (4) that is appealing to minors.

The informal, conversational nature of services such as Twitter make violation of these rules easy, too easy. And, don’t think that the OLCC won’t get wise to the use of social media. They launched their own blog in July 2008. Check it out at http://olccblog.blogspot.com/. And, what's posted on these sites, just like the rest of the internet, is expected to have a long shelf life. Before you send off your next tweet, be careful that you’re not inviting your state alcohol regulatory agency to make a visit.

You should also be careful when referring to the competition, members of the public and possibly your state regulatory agency. Keep it friendly. Think before you tweet or post. Getting sued for defamation, causing emotional distress, or just plain bad PR can follow.
 

Trademark Registration for "Place-Name" Restaurant Names Made Easier by PTO

Changes at the US Patent and Trademark Office regarding how they handle place-name marks acknowledge that consumers in restaurants are not going to be deceived about the source of their food.  This should make it easier to register place-name restaurant marks such as "Paris Cafe" located in places other than Paris. 

Examination Guide NO. 2-09 Examination Procedures for §2(a) and §2(e)(3) Deceptiveness Refusals for Geographic Marks (11 May 2009)

The elements of a §2(e)(3) refusal apply to service marks as well as marks involving goods.13 However, application of the services-place association prong is more difficult to satisfy in that the mere showing that the services at issue often emanate from the place named in the mark is not sufficient.14 This is especially true for restaurant services because, having chosen a particular restaurant, a customer is aware of the geographic location of the service and is less likely to associate the services with the place named in the mark (e.g., a customer is less likely to identify restaurant services with a region of Paris when sitting in a restaurant in New York). 15

 

Starbucks Brews a Winning Cup: Tip Pooling in California Restaurants

On June 2, 2009, a California appellate court upheld Starbucks’ mandatory tip-sharing policy, saying that Starbucks does not have to pay $100 million in additional wages to its baristas.

Reversing a trial court judgment, the Court of Appeal held that Starbuck’s policy requiring that tips be divided between baristas and “shift supervisors” who work along side them is permissible under California Labor Code Section 351.

Continue Reading...

Starbucks Brews a Winning Cup: Tip Pooling in California Restaurants

On June 2, 2009, a California appellate court upheld Starbucks’ mandatory tip-sharing policy, saying that Starbucks does not have to pay $100 million in additional wages to its baristas.

Reversing a trial court judgment, the Court of Appeal held that Starbuck’s policy requiring that tips be divided between baristas and “shift supervisors” who work along side them is permissible under California Labor Code Section 351.

Continue Reading...

Menu Labeling Compromise Reached

It looks like a compromise may have been reached regarding the nation's menu labeling laws.

Great Restaurant Service

After attending a reception and dinner at Canlis Restaurant in Seattle, Wash. - in connection with the International Trademark Association annual meeting - it was clear that there were not enough taxis to get all guests home for the evening. One of the co-owners of the restaurant pulled up his car and ferried several of us to our hotels!  Now, that's great service!!!

Trends in the Restaurant Business

The high-end restaurants are in trouble, and smart restaurateurs find ways to survive...

San Francisco's Michael Bauer talks about trends in the Restaurant Biz and quotes owners of the Lark Creek Inn, Michael Dellar and Bradley Ogden explaining the decision to change the name and format of the venerable Lark Creek Inn restaurant in Larkspur, CA:

And while the prim and proper Lark Creek Inn was our vision some 20 years ago, we now have a new vision. One prompted not only by the world economic crises, but also because the dining environment has changed of its own volition. Today, the emphasis is on neighborhood versus destination, lower prices versus higher ones and simplicity versus complexity.

Elsewhere, bars and small plates are the alternative, see "Bar Wars: To attract cash-strapped diners, restaurateurs from Alain Ducasse to Daniel Boulud are making dramatic bids to ramp up their bar business -- even if it means serving hot dogs and deviled eggs."

Nel Centro Opens in Portland's Hotel Modera

In May, restauranteur and DWT client David Machado will open Nel Centro, his new restaurant located in the Hotel Modera in downtown Portland. DWT was able to assist Mr. Machado in the negotiation of very favorable restaurant lease terms, which allowed the project to proceed despite the challenging economic environment.

Virginia Adopts Restaurant Smoking Ban

On March 9, 2009, the governor of Virginia signed into a law the latest statewide smoking ban for bars and restaurants. This was a hard-fought battle by the governor of a state with a history steeped in tobacco. Virginia joins 23 other states and Puerto Rico who have passed similar bans. However, Virginia's governor claims that this new law is the toughest in the nation’s top five tobacco-producing states.

Continue Reading...